UX health Audit: the feature that carries 90% of the platform
Submit Service Issue is how stores tell vendors something is wrong: an out-of-stock, a late delivery, a missing tag. It's used on a phone, often one-handed, on a store floor or receiving dock, across 17 configurations. Customer feedback told us people were frustrated, but not where or why. So I built a scoring model with five pillars, each anchored to a question a real user would ask, and five criteria per pillar scored from 1 (critical) to 5 (optimal).
- Clarity & Communication: Does the system keep me informed and focused?
- Intuition & Familiarity: Does this work the way I expect it to?
- Safety & Error Management: Am I allowed to make mistakes without fear?
- Efficiency & Performance: Does the system value my time and intent?
- Support & Self-Education: Is help available exactly when I need it?
UX health map
Submit Service Issue is how stores tell vendors something is wrong: an out-of-stock, a late delivery, a missing tag. It's used on a phone, often one-handed, on a store floor or receiving dock, across 17 configurations. Customer feedback told us people were frustrated, but not where or why. So I built a scoring model with five pillars, each anchored to a question a real user would ask, and five criteria per pillar.
What the scores pointed to
- Submitting felt like a gamble
Submit was hidden below the fold in 16 of 17 configurations. Errors fired all at once, up to 10+ toasts that vanished before you could read them. - The form asked backwards
Five selections before you could describe the issue, a 39-item list with no search, and duplicate alcohol issue types. - Small bugs, platform-wide reach
Invisible selected states, white-on-white focus rings and tiny tap targets. Each one was a single component breaking every form - Language that blamed the user
Routine reports were "Violations," and placeholders called optional fields required. - No safety net
No undo, no help, nothing remembered. Five alerts meant picking the same manufacturer five times.
The bright spot
Picking a manufacturer filled in the distributor. That became the principle for the rebuild: the form should do the work it can.